Ben Garner profile image

By

Ben Garner is an accomplished Maryland real estate professional recognized for his leadership, integrity, and proven results. His honors include The Daily Record’s Rising Stars, Real Producers’ Top 30 Agents in Their 30s, and rankings among the top 1% of producers in Maryland and agents nationwide.

Making Real Estate Decisions Easy. Start with a casual chat to craft a plan as unique as your story. Book a Call

One house in Greater Baltimore drew 49 offers in four days. The spread between the list price and the contract price is the part everyone wants to discuss, and it’s the part that matters least.

An estate sale that needed everything. The listing came to us through a past client. The family was in the middle of a loss and had a house to deal with on top of it. The property was built in the early nineties and had stayed there in every respect, with original light fixtures, original cabinets, original carpet, and old drywall repairs showing through the paint. Out back sat an above-ground pool that nature had reclaimed so thoroughly it had become an above-ground garden.

Competitive pricing buys volume, nothing more. Our seller wanted $500,000. We ran the comps and couldn’t get there, and realistically expected the house to land somewhere near $475,000. What we proposed instead was pricing it to move, putting it in front of as many people as possible across a single weekend, then sitting down the following week to look at what came back. We settled on $425,000.

Price is marketing, and we’ll own that all day. We won’t claim the house was $200,000 underpriced. Listing low and waiting for the market to hand over a windfall isn’t a strategy, and most of the time, it doesn’t work.

Volume is where the work begins. Within five minutes of the listing going active, showing requests were coming in. Between Wednesday and Sunday evening, we ran 133 showings, and more than 150 people came through the open houses. The agents running them told us they ran out of room on the sign-in sheet and started writing names on a folder. By 7:00 on Sunday, we had 49 offers.

“A competitive price gets you volume, and turning that volume into terms is where the job starts. ”

Every buyer was treated identically. Unrepresented buyers called us directly, and we sent each one to another agent, so we had no part in representing them. Offers went into a folder as they arrived, numbered in order, and none of them were read until the weekend closed. Our seller got one opportunity to sell that house and every buyer got one opportunity to buy it, and nobody was going to leave believing somebody else had received special treatment.

On Sunday night, at the seller’s direction, we went back to the top three and asked for highest and best. One came up at $20,000. We went under contract at $605,000, with two other offers above $600,000.

Our seller kept a real veto. Before any of this started, we told him he was the final decision maker, and that if the offers didn’t reach a number he was happy with, he could say no and the house wouldn’t sell. He held that option the entire time, and he needed to know he held it. You don’t run a weekend like this without giving someone that exit.

Fiduciary duty isn’t a disclosure line. Reviewing the contract, we gave him the number first and started through the terms. Two pages in, he stopped us and asked whether we’d said 605. It hadn’t registered the first time. He came to us during what was probably the worst month of his life and handed over what he couldn’t deal with himself.

When somebody is in no condition to make the best decisions for themselves, the person advising them has to be making those decisions on their behalf the whole way through.

Not every house needs fixing first. A lot of people assume a property that needs work has to be repaired before it can sell. That isn’t always true, and figuring out which situation you’re in is the whole ballgame.

If you’re sitting on a house that needs work and you’re not sure whether to fix it or sell it as it stands, we put together a short guide on how to tell the difference. Call or text us at 240-216-7841, email us at ben@garnerandco.com, or visit garnerandco.com. Tell us what you’re working with, and we’ll give you a straight answer.

  • Making Real Estate Decisions Easy. Start with a casual chat to craft a plan as unique as your story. Book a Call

  • Free Home Valuation. Don’t trust a Zestimate. Get a personalized home valuation directly from GARNER+CO. Get Estimate

  • Free Newsletter. Get our latest Q&A, insights, and market updates to make smarter decisions. Subscribe Now